Oil brine disposal injection wells are deep, scientifically engineered systems, akin to vertical vaults, that send brine water —naturally occurring byproducts of oil and gas production —down into rock layers that have held saltwater for millions of years, thousands of feet below the water table. The idea is to keep the byproduct of oil and gas production safely away from people and water supplies.

• In Ohio, the oversight and approval of injection wells are handled by certified professionals at the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR). Nationally, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has strict regulations that must be met.

• Wells are defined by classes. The two pertinent classes here are Class II wells, which contain oil/gas wastewater, and Class I wells, which contain industrial waste.  The wells must be drilled to allow for fluid injection thousands of feet below the lowest underground source of drinking water.

• Each well is built with multiple layers of steel casing and cement.

• Class II wells have been regulated by ODNR since 1983. The move reflected confidence that Ohio could uphold federal standards. In 1983, the EPA formally granted primacy over the regulation of Class II injection wells to ODNR.

  • This allowed Ohio to develop and enforce its own Underground Injection Control (UIC) program under the framework of the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA).

• One study out of Bakersfield, California, found that treated water used in hydraulic fracturing is safe for agricultural use.

  • The study found no significant difference between crops irrigated with treated water extracted during the oil production process and those irrigated from other sources.

• Injection pressures and operational standards are set and monitored by the ODNR.

• The ODNR coordinates step rate testing to ensure the structural integrity of injection wells.

  • Step Rate Testing is performed by injecting fluid in small steps, testing the pressure at each level. This helps identify the fracture pressure at which cracks might form. By identifying this, the injection can be made safely without damaging the surrounding rock or risking leaks.

• Many such sites, including DeepRock’s, are equipped with seismic monitoring, and wells are fitted with continuous pressure monitoring to detect anomalies that can be quickly addressed and rectified.

• Regular inspections – often unannounced – are conducted by ODNR to ensure compliance.

• Further environmental controls include filter bag testing of brine, monitoring fluid levels in tanks using radar and laser technologies to avoid overflows, and leak detection systems for the double-walled piping and containment tanks.

• The ODNR requires reports about brine volumes on a scheduled basis.

• Besides the ODNR, companies maintaining injection wells collaborate with multiple federal and state agencies, including the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (Spill Prevention, Control, and Countermeasure plan), the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (barge permit), and the U.S. Coast Guard (approved Maritime Transfer Facility & Facility Response Plan).

• The handling of this situation is a prime example of bad government in action.

• Our analysis suggests that the entire affair is a vendetta carried out by Susan Vessels.

• Council’s actions should be incredibly troubling for residents:

  • Racing toward an unwinnable lawsuit.

  • Abusing the city’s “emergency” clause to rush legislation.

  • Refusing to take a thoughtful approach, study, and report facts.

  • Council President Susan Vessels unethically recorded a private meeting and leaked it to reporters.

  • The City of Marietta has ignored lawful and routine public records requests for Susan Vessel’s communications.

  • Writing a letter in opposition that is filled with, at best, misinformation and, at worst, flat-out lies.

• Make no mistake, the threatened lawsuit is a bad deal for Marietta taxpayers. It lacks standing, is unlikely to succeed, and it will be very costly.

• The only thing being poisoned in Southeast Ohio is the truth, and Susan Vessels is the source.

• The environmental lobby and their shill, Susan Vessels, are using inflammatory, fearmongering, and speculation to aggravate the community.

• Statewide, the oil and gas industry supports hundreds of thousands of jobs across Ohio and contributes tens of billions to Ohio’s economy. The sector is responsible for 290,000 barrels of crude oil & over 6. billion cubic feet of natural gas annually.

• According to an analysis by Cleveland State University, natural gas and oil development in the Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District (MWCD) generated $1 billion in economic activity in the region over nine years, directly supporting more than 2,600 jobs totaling nearly $300 million in wages and benefits, and generating increases in state and local tax revenue and growth in related industries such as transportation, tourism, and infrastructure.

• What-ifs aren’t science. Injection wells are safe and well-regulated. Each of us can identify numerous doomsday scenarios, but hypotheticals cannot drive government policy.

• The distance between an injection well and a water source has no bearing on the potential danger. The U.S. EPA’s Underground Injection Control (UIC) program, created under the Safe Drinking Water Act, examines the well’s depth and the effectiveness of its sealing.

• The EPA requires at least one confining layer of impermeable rock. Rather than horizontal distance, science and federal law indicate that vertical depth and geologic barriers are the key considerations.

• Injection wells are drilled in stages, with each stage lined with steel casing and cement. When complete, there are up to seven layers of steel/cement of protection.

• The first casing, called the surface casing, extends deep enough, at least 100 feet, to pass below the lowest underground source of drinking water.

• There is often a concern about seismic activity around injection wells. Out of 232 active oil brine wells in Ohio, Peer-reviewed research and the ODNR have found very few tied to any sort of suspected seismic activity.

• Some have suggested that those seeking permits for injection wells must abide by newly formed regulations, despite having filed the permit application under previous rules. This is patently false.

  • Permits are considered under the regulatory environment in place at the time of filing.

• Imagine you studied hard, took your driver’s test, and passed under the existing rules. Then, a week later, someone says, “Sorry, we just changed the test. You’ll have to retake it, even though you already did everything right.” That would be unfair—and it’s not how the system works. Ohio law is clear on this subject.

• Let’s correct the record: These organizations portray themselves as saviors.

  • They don’t have your best interests at heart; they have a radical environmental agenda and are sowing discord to shut down the oil and gas industry, not one well in Washington County.

• They’re woke left-wing environmental zealots.

• EarthJustice is funded in part by the liberal MacArthur and Ford Foundations. These organizations support liberal causes such as Planned Parenthood, those pushing climate change, the ACLU, PBS, the NAACP, the Sierra Club, and the Brookings Institution.

• The Buckeye Environmental Network receives funding from the Tides Foundation, which is affiliated with Earthjustice, the MacArthur Foundation, and the Ford Foundation.

• Despite having an Athens County headquarters and a commitment to “protecting forests,” BEN has donated to numerous groups outside of Ohio, and the individuals involved have connections that are a who’s who of the environmental left.

• Let’s correct the record here, too.

• DeepRock strengthens the local economy.

  • It offers good-paying local jobs, tax revenue, and community investment through (to provide some examples) donations and/or sponsorships benefitting the Marietta Community Foundation, the Washington County Fair, and local food banks. In fact, DeepRock was recognized as Philanthropist Organization of the Year by the Marietta Community Foundation in 2023.

  • Its employees live and raise families in Marietta, giving them a personal stake in maintaining safe, environmentally responsible operations—especially when it comes to protecting the local drinking water.

• DeepRock is NOT Brian Chavez.

  • Senator Chavez’s family owns an interest in DeepRock, but he stepped away from active involvement when he was appointed to the State Senate.

  • Under Senate ethics rules, Senator Chavez must be careful to avoid conflicts of interest and has done so.

  • As the Energy Committee Chairman, he believes that Ohio’s energy sector is an essential driver of our economy, and he’s in a unique position to help ensure that the industry acts safely on behalf of Ohio residents while avoiding the regulatory burden sought by environmental activists intent on strangling the sector.